Tutorial :What audio format works for Silverlight + WPF?



Question:

I'm writing a pair of applications for distributing audio (among other features). I have a WPF program that allows an artist to record and edit audio. Clicking a button then uploads this to a silverlight-powered website. A consumer visiting this website can then listen to the audio. Simple. It works. But I'd like it to be better: I need an audio format that works seamlessly on both the recording and playback sides.

I'm currently using mp3 format, and I'm not happy with it. For the recording/editing, I use the Alvas Audio c# library. It works ok, but for MP3 recording requires that the artist goes into his registry to change msacm.l3acm to l3codecp.acm. That's a lot to ask of an end-user. Furthermore mp3 recording seems rather fragile when I install on a new machine. (Sometimes it randomly just doesn't work until you've fiddled around for a while. I still don't know why.) I've been told that unless I want to pay royalties to the mp3 patent holders, I always need to rely on this type of registry change.

So what other audio format could I use instead? I need something compressed. Alvas audio can also record to GSM, for example, but that won't play back in silverlight. Silverlight will play WMA, but I don't know how to record in that format - Alvas Audio won't. I'd be open to using another recording library instead, but I haven't managed to find one.

Am I missing something obvious, or is there really no user-friendly way to record audio in WPF and play it back in Silverlight? It seems like there should be...

Any suggestions greatly appreciated.

Thanks.


Solution:1

IMO, WMA would be your best bet. I'm not sure how your application is setup or how low level you want to go, but the Windows Media Format SDK is a great way to encode WMA and the runtimes come with Windows. There are .NET PIAs and samples for it here: http://windowsmedianet.sourceforge.net/


Solution:2

Given that Ogg Vorbis is being adopted for the new HTML audio tag in (cough) some browsers, it's probably worth checking it out. You won't get bitten by any licensing concerns if you follow this route. If ease of deployment is top of your list, then go with WMA.

[tries hard not to start ranting about fragmented state of codec options in browsers and the commercial interests that scupper any concensus]


Note:If u also have question or solution just comment us below or mail us on toontricks1994@gmail.com
Previous
Next Post »